
Last month’s contest featured a drawing by New Yorker cartoonist David Ostow, who joined us on the judging panel.
His cartoon is set in the Garden of Eden, where God is standing next to and pointing at a breakfast buffet—the kind you see in hotels—and addressing Adam and Eve, who are standing under the Tree of Knowledge. The snake is at their feet. Their genitals are covered with fig leaves, implying that they have already eaten the forbidden fruit and are consequently experiencing a sense of shame. Adam is holding the fruit—an apple—in his right hand, and it looks like he might be trying to hide it from God.
David’s original caption suggested that Adam and Eve could have lived forever in paradise had they just waited five minutes before eating: “It’s 6:55. The breakfast bar was literally about to open.”
Several of you went after the same joke while highlighting God’s exasperation:
- “Six days creating the world. Another day cooking. And you eat an apple?”
- “If you could have just waited fifteen minutes.”
- “I’m really trying to help you here!”
- “I put out a waffle station. A WAFFLE STATION.”
That last caption reminds me of the way Tracy Jordan, a character on 30 Rock, often delivered a joke by repeating the final words of a sentence to land the punchline.
A few entries led to some fairly ridiculous theological debates. For instance, we all liked, “Fresh cream. I made the cow this morning.” But then Bob argued that it worked only if God created the beasts of the field after creating Adam and Eve. We checked and, according to Genesis, God made cows on Day Five before creating humankind at the end of Day Six. Next, we argued about this entry: “If you need salt, there’s a pillar here somewhere.” Unfortunately, the Torah does not mention pillars of salt until Lot’s wife is turned into one more than 2,000 years after God banished Adam and Eve from the Garden. Finally, we considered a pretty good Jewish joke: “Enjoy the bacon while you still can.” That works perfectly, as pork was not deemed unkosher until Leviticus 11:7.
We all liked the way this entry addresses Adam’s apparent attempt to hide the forbidden fruit from God: “What part of omniscient don’t you understand?” Unfortunately, that caption completely ignores the buffet.
Several of you alluded to Adam and Eve’s expulsion from the Garden:
- “You will now, by the sweat of your brow, make your own waffles.”
- “Henceforth, you will make your own waffles.”
- “The buffet is only for guests who are staying.”
- “Have some breakfast before you check out.”
- “You want a ‘to go’ box?”
I assume the following two nearly identical captions were submitted by the same person who was trying to figure out which version of the joke works best:
- “The buffet is free, but the apples will cost you.”
- “The buffet is free, but the apple will cost you.”
Both are fine, but they don’t compare to, “Fuck the apple. Who ate my forbidden muffin?” We don’t usually reward entries that contain such strong profanity—especially when the expletive is just a lazy way to provoke a reaction—but in this case the word “fuck” is an indispensable part of the caption. To understand why, consider substituting the word “forget” for the word “fuck.” It’s essentially the same joke, but the more shocking version, which suggests that God is not just all-powerful but pretty vulgar, is much funnier. That said, I hope I have not encouraged any of you to submit captions that are simply crude. They need to be clever and funny, too.
This entry cleverly acknowledges that Adam and Eve are the only two people on Earth: “I made enough to feed the entire human race.”
Several of you alluded to the fact that most breakfast buffets are unhealthy, unappetizing, or both:
- “Do not eat from the tree of knowledge. Also, I’d avoid the powdered eggs.”
- “This could be the second biggest mistake you make today.”
- “The real sin here is the challah French toast casserole.”
- “It’s not forbidden, it’s just really bad.”
- “It’s all you shouldn’t eat.”
Here’s the month’s best pun: “Time to meet your waffle maker.” The second-best suggests that God made bad Italian chain-restaurants at the same time he created the world: “Unlimited breadsticks? That’s the other garden.” But shouldn’t “garden” be capitalized since it’s a proper noun?
Here’s the best entry that specifically addressed the serpent in the Garden: “The snake never mentioned the breakfast buffet?”
I loved this caption—“All you can eat, not everything you can eat.”—as it cleverly addressed both breakfast buffets and forbidden fruit, but it would work better if the word “all” were underlined, italicized, or capitalized for emphasis and therefore drew a sharper distinction between what is and is not allowed. (If you cannot use italics or the underline function when submitting an entry, capitalize the word.)
Here were the best genitalia jokes:
- “Watch out for the waffle iron.”
- “Those leaves were meant for the salad.”
- “Those were for the salad!”
The last two captions are essentially the same joke, but the shorter version is slightly better because it refers to the leaves without mentioning them specifically. I could do without the exclamation point, but it works if you assume God is yelling, which under the circumstances he might be.
I like both these references to the Tree of Knowledge:
- “And here’s the buffet. From which you’ll learn absolutely nothing.”
- “You’ll need that extra knowledge to work the waffle machine.”
This entry suggests that not all apples in the Garden of Eden are forbidden: “What’s wrong with the apples in the fruit bowl?”
While these next two entries suggest that the apple in Adam’s hand is not strictly forbidden—just not something to have right before a large meal:
- “Don’t eat that. It’ll spoil your dinner.”
- “Don’t tell me you’ve already eaten.”
Here was the month’s best joke about pareidolia, which makes some people imagine they’re seeing a familiar image, like a religious figure, in a common object, like a piece of toast: “If you see my face in the toast, butter around it.” If you see God’s image in your toast, don’t butter around it, sell it. In 2004, Diane Duyser sold a 10-year-old grilled cheese sandwich with an image that she believed to be the Virgin Mary for $28,000 (nearly $50,000 today) on eBay.
Finally, we have a caption which suggests that God is reluctantly resigned to the fact that Adam and Eve ignore his rules: “I’d say help yourselves, but when have you ever needed my permission?”
Congratulations to GREGORY HOWE, who will receive half the pot ($570.62) for his winning caption: “Do not eat from the tree of knowledge. Also, I’d avoid the powdered eggs.” Not only is it clever and funny; it has a nice rhythm.
The following five runners-up will each receive $114.11:
- “Fuck the apple. Who ate my forbidden muffin?” PETER DRAWBRIDGE
- “It’s not forbidden, it’s just really bad.” JANE CERHAN
- “Don’t tell me you’ve already eaten.” HENRY SAMPSON
- “Those were for the salad!” MARK KAVANAUGH
- “You want a ‘to go’ box?” MELISSA GUENSLER
IIf you who want to see how we made our selections, we recorded the process and posted it on our YouTube Channel.
Like what you see? Subscribe to our YouTube channel for more Caption Contest episodes.
Just a reminder, the rules have changed a bit. The winner will get half the money we collect from entrants (which could be far more or far less than $500, depending on the level of participation), and the five runners-up will split the balance. Furthermore, there is no longer a limit to the number of entries you may submit, but after the first three you submit for an entrance fee of $5.00, each additional entry costs $3.00.
The prize money increases with each participant, so encourage your friends to play.
And if you haven’t yet ordered my book on the caption contest even though it’s been out for almost two years, click on the following link:



